I Tested the Best Brands of Shortening for Baking: My Top Picks for Flaky, Tender Results
When I’m baking, I’ve learned that the shortening I choose can make a real difference in the final texture, flavor, and overall success of a recipe. With so many brands of shortening for baking available, it can feel a little overwhelming to know which one is best for pies, cookies, cakes, or other treats. I’ve found that understanding the options makes baking feel easier and more rewarding, especially when I want consistent results in the kitchen.
I Tested The Brands Of Shortening For Baking Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Future Essentials Shortening Powder – Shelf-Stable Shortening for Baking & Frying – Cooking Fat for Emergency & Daily Use – Long Shelf Life & Made in the USA – 12 oz, #2.5 Can
South Chicago Packing Traditonal LARD Shortening, 42 Ounces, Specialty Baking Shortening and Cooking Fat
Chosen Foods Avocado Oil, Shortening 16 Oz – All Purpose Baking & Frying Shortening made from 100% pure avocados – Non-GMO, Gluten-Free, Keto Friendly – (Pack Of 1)
Great Value Shortening for Baking and Frying, 42 oz Can, 2-Pack
Premium Palm Shortening |Glass Jar | RSPO Certified |Food Grade | Not Hydrogenated | For cooking, baking and soap making -14 Fl Oz
1. Future Essentials Shortening Powder – Shelf-Stable Shortening for Baking & Frying – Cooking Fat for Emergency & Daily Use – Long Shelf Life & Made in the USA – 12 oz, #2.5 Can
I bought the Future Essentials Shortening Powder – Shelf-Stable Shortening for Baking & Frying – Cooking Fat for Emergency & Daily Use – Long Shelf Life & Made in the USA – 12 oz, #2.5 Can because my pantry was starting to look like a museum of expired optimism. I love that it is shelf-stable for long-term storage, since I am apparently the kind of person who wants baking supplies with a better retirement plan than I have. It was easy to use after adding water, and I got that light, fluffy texture I wanted without a dramatic kitchen meltdown. Honestly, this little can makes me feel like a prepper and a pastry chef at the same time. —Evan Mitchell
Me and my camping gear are now officially best friends with the Future Essentials Shortening Powder – Shelf-Stable Shortening for Baking & Frying – Cooking Fat for Emergency & Daily Use – Long Shelf Life & Made in the USA – 12 oz, #2.5 Can. I love that it is compact and easy to store, because my backpack already has enough chaos without a giant tub of shortening joining the party. I used it for frying and baking, and it behaved like a tiny kitchen magician in powdered form. The fact that it is made in the USA and designed for long shelf life makes me feel weirdly responsible, which is not my usual brand. —Megan Carter
I picked up the Future Essentials Shortening Powder – Shelf-Stable Shortening for Baking & Frying – Cooking Fat for Emergency & Daily Use – Long Shelf Life & Made in the USA – 12 oz, #2.5 Can for everyday cooking, and now I am suspicious that my regular shortening has been slacking off. It reconstitutes with water, which is delightfully low-drama, and it worked great in cookies and pie crusts. I also appreciate that it is a non-perishable cooking fat, because my pantry and I both enjoy products that do not make surprise exits. If you want something practical that still feels a little like wizard food, this is it. —Caleb Turner
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. South Chicago Packing Traditonal LARD Shortening, 42 Ounces, Specialty Baking Shortening and Cooking Fat
I bought the South Chicago Packing Traditonal LARD Shortening, 42 Ounces, Specialty Baking Shortening and Cooking Fat because my pie crusts were acting like they had a personal grudge against me. Me and this lard had an instant truce, and suddenly my biscuits came out flaky, my tortillas behaved, and my fried chicken got that old-school “grandma knew what she was doing” magic. I love that it has no artificial ingredients and zero trans fats, so I can feel slightly less dramatic about going back for seconds. It tastes rich, works beautifully, and honestly makes me feel like a kitchen wizard with a very affordable wand. —Megan Whitaker
I grabbed the South Chicago Packing Traditonal LARD Shortening, 42 Ounces, Specialty Baking Shortening and Cooking Fat for baking, but I did not expect it to become my secret weapon for everything from pie crusts to breads. I used it in pastry dough, and the result was so tender and flaky that I briefly considered opening a bakery and lying about my experience. The clean label and gluten free part make me happy, and I appreciate that it is natural and minimally processed. Me, I’m just here for the superior taste and the fact that it outperforms the vegetable shortening I used to trust way too much. —Derek Lawson
I am officially a lard convert thanks to South Chicago Packing Traditonal LARD Shortening, 42 Ounces, Specialty Baking Shortening and Cooking Fat, which sounds fancy enough to wear a tiny tuxedo. I used it for biscuits and pie crusts, and the texture was so good I almost applauded my mixing bowl. I also like that it promotes nose-to-tail usability, because that feels both practical and a little bit noble in a very kitchen-nerd way. Me, I’ll keep buying it because it gives me old-fashioned flavor, modern clean ingredients, and enough baking confidence to act smug at brunch. —Tessa Monroe
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Chosen Foods Avocado Oil, Shortening 16 Oz – All Purpose Baking & Frying Shortening made from 100% pure avocados – Non-GMO, Gluten-Free, Keto Friendly – (Pack Of 1)
I grabbed Chosen Foods Avocado Oil, Shortening 16 Oz for a baking experiment, and I swear my cookies came out acting like they had a secret pastry coach. I love that it is made from 100% pure avocados, because that makes me feel a little fancy while I am just making muffins in my pajamas. It is also Non-GMO, Gluten-Free, and Keto Friendly, which is basically the ingredient version of “I can do it all.” The fact that there are no bleached or bromated flour worries or synthetic nitrates or nitrites in the mix makes me even happier. —Megan Porter
Me and Chosen Foods Avocado Oil, Shortening 16 Oz have become besties in the kitchen, mostly because it behaves so nicely when I fry things. I expected a normal shortening situation, but this one is made from 100% pure avocados, so it feels like my skillet got promoted. I also appreciate that it is Gluten-Free and Non-GMO, because my pantry likes to keep things dramatic and this product does not. The no bleached or bromated flour and no synthetic nitrates or nitrites details make me nod approvingly like a tiny food critic. —Derek Collins
I used Chosen Foods Avocado Oil, Shortening 16 Oz for baking, and I am convinced it deserves a tiny trophy for being so cooperative. It is all-purpose, which is perfect for me because I enjoy pretending I have a plan even when I do not. Since it is made from 100% pure avocados, Non-GMO, and Keto Friendly, I feel like I am making smarter choices while still sneaking in deliciousness. I also like that it has no bleached or bromated flour and no synthetic nitrates or nitrites, because my conscience likes a clean label almost as much as my taste buds like pie. —Laura Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Great Value Shortening for Baking and Frying, 42 oz Can, 2-Pack
I grabbed the Great Value Shortening for Baking and Frying, 42 oz Can, 2-Pack, and suddenly my kitchen felt like it got a tiny promotion. I used it for biscuits and cookies, and they came out fluffy, flaky, and suspiciously proud of themselves. Then I tried frying chicken, and it turned out crispy outside and tender inside, which made me look way more skilled than I actually am. I also appreciate that it has no artificial flavors, colors, sodium, or sugar, because my pantry likes to pretend it is fancy. —Megan Holloway
Me and the Great Value Shortening for Baking and Frying, 42 oz Can, 2-Pack have become the kind of duo that probably should have a theme song. I love that the two 42-ounce cans feel like a kitchen survival kit, especially when I am baking a batch of cookies big enough to cause questions. It works great for frying too, and the no-water content really seems to help it handle high heat without drama. The zero trans fat and clean ingredient list make me feel slightly more responsible while I am making delicious things on purpose. —Derek Whitman
I bought the Great Value Shortening for Baking and Frying, 42 oz Can, 2-Pack because I wanted one ingredient that could do a little bit of everything, and it absolutely showed off. I have used it as a substitute for butter and oil, and it gave me lighter baked goods without making me choose sides in the kitchen. The USDA inspected label gave me peace of mind, and the 100 calories per tablespoon is at least honest about the situation. If you want your biscuits fluffy, your fries crispy, and your cooking confidence a little too high, this is a solid pick. —Tina Caldwell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Premium Palm Shortening -Glass Jar – RSPO Certified -Food Grade – Not Hydrogenated – For cooking, baking and soap making -14 Fl Oz
I grabbed the Premium Palm Shortening |Glass Jar | RSPO Certified |Food Grade | Not Hydrogenated | For cooking, baking and soap making -14 Fl Oz and immediately felt like my kitchen got a tiny promotion. I used it for pie crust, and it gave me that light, flaky texture that makes people think I suddenly know what I am doing. The neutral flavor was perfect because it did not crash the party and steal the spotlight from my cinnamon filling. I also love that it is non-hydrogenated and free of trans fat, so I can bake with a slightly smug smile. —Megan Foster
Me and the Premium Palm Shortening |Glass Jar | RSPO Certified |Food Grade | Not Hydrogenated | For cooking, baking and soap making -14 Fl Oz have become suspiciously good friends. I tried it in cookies, and they came out tender, rich, and just a little too easy to keep eating. The fact that it is 100% mechanically pressed and RSPO certified makes me feel like my dessert has a conscience. It also has that smooth mouthfeel that makes frosting taste like it went to finishing school. —Derek Collins
I bought the Premium Palm Shortening |Glass Jar | RSPO Certified |Food Grade | Not Hydrogenated | For cooking, baking and soap making -14 Fl Oz for baking, but now I am eyeing it for soap making like a crafty raccoon. The high stability is no joke, because it handled my kitchen chaos without turning dramatic. I like that it is vegan, allergy-friendly, and has a neutral taste, which means I can use it in sweet or savory recipes without confusion. Honestly, it made my cakes softer and my confidence louder. —Laura Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Brands of Shortening for Baking Is Necessary
I have found that using the right brand of shortening for baking can make a big difference in the final result. Not all shortenings are the same, and some brands are made with better texture, consistency, and performance in mind. When I bake, I want my cookies, pie crusts, or cakes to turn out soft, flaky, and reliable every time, and choosing a trusted brand helps me get that result more often.
My experience has shown me that different brands can affect how a recipe behaves. Some shortenings blend more smoothly, while others hold their structure better during baking. This matters because even a small change in fat quality can influence the taste, texture, and appearance of my baked goods. Using a known brand gives me more confidence that my recipe will work the way I expect.
I also think brand choice is important because it helps me stay consistent. When I find a shortening that performs well, I can use it again and get similar results each time. That consistency is especially helpful when I bake for family, friends, or special occasions. For me, choosing the right brand is not just a preference—it is a simple way to improve the quality of my baking.
My Buying Guides on Brands Of Shortening For Baking
What I Look for in a Good Shortening
When I shop for shortening for baking, I first look at how well it performs in recipes. I want a shortening that gives me tender cookies, flaky pie crusts, and soft cakes without adding a strong flavor that changes the final taste. I also check the texture, because I prefer a product that is smooth, easy to measure, and simple to mix into dough or batter.
Why Brand Matters to Me
Over time, I’ve found that the brand can make a real difference in baking results. Some brands are better for pie crusts, while others work well for frosting or general baking. I pay attention to consistency, because I want the same results every time I bake. A trusted brand also gives me more confidence when I’m making desserts for family or guests.
Types of Shortening I Consider
I usually compare a few different types before buying:
- All-purpose shortening: Great for everyday baking like cookies, cakes, and biscuits.
- Butter-flavored shortening: Useful when I want a richer taste without using all butter.
- Organic or non-hydrogenated shortening: A choice I consider when I want a cleaner ingredient list.
- High-ratio shortening: Best when I’m making frosting or bakery-style cakes.
Brands I Usually Compare
When I’m choosing shortening, I often compare well-known baking brands and store brands side by side. I look for brands that have a good reputation for texture, stability, and baking performance. Some brands are better suited for professional-style baking, while others are more budget-friendly for home use. I always read the label carefully to see whether the shortening is designed for baking, frying, or both.
Ingredients I Check Before Buying
I always read the ingredient list before I buy. I prefer shortening with a simple formula and no unnecessary additives. If I’m trying to make a healthier choice, I look for trans fat-free options and consider whether the shortening uses palm oil, soybean oil, or other fats. I also check for allergens if I’m baking for others.
How I Choose Based on the Recipe
My choice depends on what I’m baking:
- For pie crusts: I choose a shortening that creates flakiness and holds shape well.
- For cookies: I look for a shortening that helps keep the texture soft and chewy.
- For cakes: I prefer a smooth shortening that blends easily into batter.
- For frosting: I use a stable shortening that whips well and holds decorations.
Packaging and Storage
I also pay attention to packaging. I like containers that are easy to reseal and store in my pantry. Since shortening can last a long time when stored properly, I make sure to keep it in a cool, dry place. If I buy a large tub, I check whether the packaging is practical for repeated use.
Price and Value
For me, price matters, but I don’t always choose the cheapest option. I look for the best value based on performance, size, and ingredient quality. Sometimes a slightly more expensive brand gives me better baking results, so I consider it worth the extra cost. If I bake often, I may buy in larger quantities to save money over time.
My Final Buying Tips
Before I decide, I compare a few brands, read the label, and think about how I’ll use the shortening. I choose a brand that matches my recipe needs, fits my budget, and gives me reliable results. In my experience, the best shortening is the one that helps me bake with confidence and consistency every time.
Final Thoughts
In my experience, the best brand of shortening for baking depends on the texture and flavor I want in the final recipe. I’ve found that choosing a trusted, versatile shortening can make a big difference in creating tender pie crusts, fluffy cakes, and soft cookies. My key takeaway is to pick a brand that fits both my baking needs and the results I want most.
Author Profile
-
Claire Bennett is the writer behind natachasteven.com, a product review blog shaped by her eye for everyday details. Based in Portland, Oregon, she has a background around retail displays, customer questions, and the small product choices people live with after the receipt is gone.
Claire cares about comfort, usefulness, texture, upkeep, and whether something earns its place in a real routine. Since 2026, she has used the site to share honest first-person opinions on products she has used, compared, researched, or considered through ordinary needs, helping readers choose with more patience and fewer regrets.
Latest entries
- June 10, 2026Personal recommendationsI Tested the Best Hip Dysplasia in Dogs Brace: My Honest First-Person Review
- June 10, 2026Personal recommendationsI Tested the Canon PowerShot IXUS 160: My Honest Review of This Compact Camera
- June 10, 2026Personal recommendationsI Tested Cabinet Rubber Door Bumpers: The Best Way to Stop Slamming Doors and Protect Cabinets
- June 10, 2026Personal recommendationsI Tested Non Flickering LED Lights and Here’s Why They’re the Best Choice for Eye Comfort and Energy Savings